“What’s this moderate-income tract doing right outside your assessment area?”
If you’re a CRA Officer, hearing this question from an examiner can make your stomach drop. Why is there a moderate-income tract right outside your AA? Even worse, why is it only half a mile away from one of your bank branches?
If you don’t know the answer, then you probably aren’t watching your bank’s assessment areas closely enough. And if the answer is “I’m new here. Jane used to manage the AAs,” then it’s time to jump in with both feet and figure out what’s going on with your bank’s AAs.
Well-managed assessment areas are the backbone of your bank’s Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) efforts. Lending distribution, community development credit, and performance context are all evaluated inside these lines. If your AAs are wrong, so is everything measured against them.
There are three main things you need to know when it comes to CRA assessment areas:
-
How to draw and define your AAs
-
How to defend your AAs to examiners
-
When to redraw the boundaries
Without a clear process in place for defining, defending, and updating your assessment areas, your bank’s CRA performance can look worse (or better) than it really is. Examiners wondering why that moderate-income tract isn’t covered will be the least of your worries.
(By the way, if you really are new to the CRA, check out our guide for new CRA professionals.)
What is a CRA Assessment Area?
Before we get into drawing, defining, and updating assessment areas, it’s important to first understand what an assessment area actually is.
Assessment areas are part of the Community Reinvestment Act, or CRA for short. In very basic terms, the CRA is meant to ensure that banks adequately meet the credit needs of their communities. That’s a very simple explanation, and if you want to learn more about the CRA and why it’s important for banks, check out this article.
Now for assessment areas. Under the CRA, every bank is expected to define the geographic region(s) in which it plans to serve its communities. These geographic regions are called assessment areas. Regulators evaluate a bank’s lending, investments, and services within these boundaries to determine how well the institution is meeting the credit needs.

Assessment Area Rules
Knowing how to properly define your bank’s assessment areas starts with understanding the rules.
Under CRA regulations, a bank’s assessment area(s) must:
-
Reflect where the bank has a main office, branches, and deposit-taking ATMs
-
Include the surrounding geographies where the bank makes a substantial portion of its loans
-
Consist of whole census tracts, and generally whole counties, cities, or MSAs (trimming is allowed if you can justify it)
-
Not extend substantially across an MSA or state line (unless the AA is in a multistate MSA, draw separate assessment areas instead)
-
Not reflect illegal discrimination (for example, excluding majority-minority neighborhoods)
-
Not arbitrarily exclude low- or moderate-income (LMI) neighborhoods
For example, say your bank has a branch in Layton, Utah. The census tract where that branch sits has to be in your assessment area, and in most cases you’d start with the surrounding city or county. Now say your nearest branch is actually in Ogden, but you make a substantial share of your loans in Layton. Since Layton is nearby, it should be in your AA too, even though it’s in a different county. And whichever way Layton ends up in your assessment area, you can’t carve out its low- or moderate-income neighborhoods just because they’re LMI.
How to Draw Your Assessment Areas, Step by Step
Whether you’re drawing an AA for a new branch or rechecking one Jane drew in 2014, the process is the same…
Map your physical footprint (branches, ATMs, main office)
Let’s start with the easy part. Plot your main office, every branch, and every deposit-taking ATM. Cash-only ATMs and loan production offices don’t count, since they can’t take deposits.
Some banks still do this with a paper map and a box of pushpins. That works, but geocoding software built for banks makes this step (and every step after it) much faster. If you’re new to geocoding, our guide to geocoding for banks covers the basics, and our complete guide to mapping CRA assessment areas goes deeper on the mapping itself.
Geocode and plot your lending to see where loans actually go
Next, take your geocoding one step further and plot where your bank’s loans actually go. Under the regulation, that means loans you’ve originated or purchased, including home mortgage, small business, and small farm loans, plus any other loans you choose to include (like consumer loans). If you’re a HMDA reporter, your LAR already has most of your mortgage data geocoded.
You’re looking for two things. The first is where your lending clusters around your branches. Those surrounding tracts are the “substantial portion” the rule is talking about. (The regulation doesn’t put a number on “substantial,” so this is a judgment call you’ll want to document.)
The second is how much of your lending falls outside the lines entirely. Examiners look at what share of your loans you make inside your assessment areas, so a big slice of lending outside them is worth understanding before your exam, not during it.

Start with whole counties or MSAs, then justify any trimming
With your branches and loans on the map, you can decide which geographies belong in each assessment area. Your AAs have to use whole census tracts, and they generally consist of whole counties, cities, or MSAs. That makes the county or MSA around your branches the natural starting point.
From there, you can trim down to the portion you can reasonably be expected to serve. The regulation says this is especially appropriate when an assessment area would otherwise be extremely large, oddly shaped, or divided by a major geographic barrier. Take Utah’s Box Elder County, for example. A bank with a branch in Brigham City probably can’t reasonably serve the desert tracts out by the Nevada border, so trimming them makes sense.
What you can’t do is trim for convenience. Every cut needs a reason you could explain to an examiner in a sentence or two.
Check the edges for LMI and majority-minority tracts
Once you have a draft boundary, zoom in on the edges. Remember that examiner question from the beginning? You don’t want to exclude any low- or moderate-income tracts, even if it’s not intentionally discriminatory. For each tract just outside your lines, ask:
-
Is it low- or moderate-income?
-
Is it majority-minority?
-
Are you receiving applications or making loans there, and how does your lending compare with other lenders in that tract?
If an excluded tract checks any of those boxes, you need a solid, documented reason for leaving it out. An exclusion doesn’t have to be intentional to cause problems. If the pattern looks arbitrary, examiners can redraw your assessment area for you. And if the excluded tracts are mostly majority-minority, a delineation question can turn into a redlining finding.
Write down your reasoning
The last step is to always, always write down your reasoning. Why did you include that tract? Why did you trim that county? What data did you look at, and when? Everything needs a reason, and documenting it now means you won’t have to pull it from memory when an examiner asks.
Keep that documentation with the map of each assessment area somewhere you can easily access it. Future you, and your examiner, will thank you.
How to Defend Your AAs to Examiners
Drawing a good assessment area is only half the job. Now you have to explain your assessment areas (sometimes years later) during your bank’s CRA exams.
One of the first things an examiner will do is confirm that your AAs meet all the rule requirements (remember the list earlier?). If your AAs do not meet the requirements, examiners can create their own assessment areas to evaluate your bank against. This can lead to surprises if your AAs aren’t what you expected.
The best CRA exam is an uneventful one, so having your AAs ready is one way to help the exam go smoothly. Here are some tips for getting examiners to agree.
Keep a delineation file for every assessment area
You already have to create a map of each assessment area for your CRA public file. But just having a map doesn’t tell the whole story. In addition to your public file, you might want to keep your AA maps and additional information in a place where examiners can easily view them. You might include:
-
The date you drew or last reviewed the boundary, and who signed off
-
The branch and lending data you used to draw it
-
Your reason for every county or city you trimmed
-
Your analysis of the tracts just outside the edges
-
Any changes since your last exam, and why you made them
Many banks also have management or the board approve their assessment areas each year. This isn’t required by the regulation, but it’s a great way to remember to review your AAs each year and keep leadership in the loop.
Run the numbers before your examiner does
CRA exams are not when you want to be surprised. Let’s leave that to birthday parties and free donut days at work.
To avoid an unwanted surprise, make sure to run the numbers yourself before an examiner does. You know what data an examiner is going to look at, so you should double-check everything and make sure that the answers you get are what you expect.
Before each exam, check:
-
What share of your loans fall inside your assessment areas
-
How your lending in LMI tracts compares with the area’s demographics and with other lenders
-
Whether any LMI or majority-minority tracts sit just outside your lines, and how your lending there compares with other lenders’ lending
That last comparison is especially important. While separate from the CRA exam, fair lending examiners will also look at your AAs when assessing redlining risk. An AA that skips minority neighborhoods that other lenders serve is exactly what they’re looking for.
If you do find a problem, fix it and document the fix before your exam. Examiners would much rather see a note explaining a problem you fixed last year than be the one to break the news to you. They like uneventful exams, too.

Make your answers easy to understand and check
When you do receive questions from an examiner (which is bound to happen eventually no matter how much prep you do), it’s best to give explanations that are short, specific, and backed by data the examiner can see.
For example, which of these answers would you rather receive when asking “Why does your Box Elder County AA stop where it does?”
-
“We’ve always drawn it that way.”
-
“The western part of the county is mostly desert, well beyond what our Brigham City branch can reasonably serve. We made two loans there in the last three years. Here’s the lending map and our annual review.”
Clearly, the second answer is better than the first. The first answer will only bring frustration and more follow-up questions. The second answer anticipates questions and provides all the information needed, backed by real results and a visual depiction. It’s also easy for examiners to confirm for themselves.
If your examiner disagrees
Sometimes you and your examiner will see a boundary differently. That’s just the nature of CRA exams, no matter how prepared you are. Instead of arguing about what counts, it’s best to focus on building a strong relationship with that examiner. Always acknowledge their concerns, ask what specifically they see as noncompliant, share your documentation and any performance context they might be missing, and keep the conversation focused on the rules.
If you still can’t come to an agreement, that’s okay! It might be noted in your exam findings, and each regulator has a formal appeals process. Either way, your documentation is what your case will rest on.
When to Redraw the Boundaries
You’ve defined your assessment areas and defended them during an exam. You’re doing great, but there’s still one more step: redrawing your boundaries.
“Redrawing?” you might ask. “But we just did that!”
Sorry to burst your bubble, but assessment areas are not a “one-and-done” kind of deal. As your bank changes, so should your AAs. While you’re free to review your AAs at any time, you should plan to do so whenever one of these situations comes up:
Branch openings, closings, and relocations
A new branch in a new county needs to be in an assessment area, either by expanding an existing AA or drawing a new one. Closing a branch works the other way. If that branch was the reason a county was in your AA, you may be able to shrink the boundary. Just make sure you aren’t trimming LMI tracts without a documented reason.

Mergers and acquisitions
Buying another bank means inheriting its branches, its lending footprint, and usually its assessment areas. Those boundaries were drawn by someone else, for a different bank, so check them against your own rules before you claim them as your own.
Census tract changes
Tract income levels shift as new census data comes out, so a tract you excluded as middle-income may now be moderate-income. That exclusion was easy to explain when you made it, but it might not be anymore. Tract boundaries can also change after each census, which means your AA map may need to be redrawn even if nothing about your bank changed.
Changes in where your lending goes
A new loan product, a new loan officer, or steady growth into a neighboring county can all shift where your loans cluster. If you’re now making a substantial share of loans in tracts next to your AA, those tracts may belong inside it.
An upcoming exam
Give your AAs a final review a few months before your exam, not a few days. That leaves time to fix anything you find and document the fix.
Reviewing your assessment areas does not guarantee a redraw. If your AAs still meet the rule requirements and adequately reflect your bank’s lending, then just reviewing them might be enough. But if major changes have been made, then redrawing your assessment areas will help ensure accurate reporting and smooth exams.
When Everything Comes Together
Remember the examiner’s question from the beginning of this article? Here’s how the conversation goes when your assessment areas are in good shape:
Examiner: “What’s this moderate-income tract doing right outside your assessment area?”
You: “That tract is across the state line, outside our MSA. Our branch is several miles away, and our AA can’t extend substantially into another state, even though we’ve made a handful of loans there in the last five years. Here’s the lending map and the note from our last annual review.”
It took thirty seconds, and now your examiner has everything they need and can move on.
That’s the difference a documented assessment area makes. It isn’t about having perfect boundaries or beautifully color-coded maps. It’s about having a reason for every boundary and being able to show why you made each choice. Because your AAs set the bar for your whole CRA exam, getting them right makes everything measured inside them more accurate, too.
It might sound like a lot to manage, but there are plenty of tools that can help you understand, draw, and visualize your bank’s assessment areas. For example, Kadince software can help you geocode and map your branches and loans to draw your AAs, then track loans, investments, and services by assessment area so you always know where you stand.
If you want to see how Kadince makes this easy, schedule a demo with our team.
None of Kadince, Inc., its affiliates, or its respective employees, directors, officers, and agents (collectively, “Kadince”) are responsible or liable for any content or information incorporated herein. Read full disclosure.

